Dream Factory

Hidden Subset – Finding Hidden Pairs and Triples

Classic & Cube

This technique works on a single 9×9 grid and on the cube alike. The in-app hint system knows and explains it.

Key rule: When the same number of digits can appear only inside that exact number of cells, those cells belong to them and every other candidate inside those cells can be eliminated.

If two digits in a row, column, or block appear only in the same two cells, they must go in those two cells. That is a Hidden Pair. Three digits restricted to the same three cells form a Hidden Triple, and four form a Hidden Quad. Because both digits of a pair need a home in the group and only two spots exist, those two cells are completely booked: eliminate all other candidates from them.

This is the mirror image of a Naked Subset. There you start from the cells: two cells have only two candidates left. Here you start from the digits. The group is “hidden” because extra candidates still clutter those cells until you check where each digit can appear.

How to read this page

A candidate is a digit that can still go in an empty cell after checking every face it belongs to. For an edge cell, check both faces; for a corner cell, check all three. In the app, you record candidates as pencil notes. {2, 7} means only 2 or 7 can still go here.

Row 4, Column 7 is the cell in Row 4, Column 7 of the face shown: 4 down, 7 across. Rows are counted from the top and columns from the left, starting at 1. The same arrows appear in the corner of each diagram: ↓ above the row numbers, → before the column numbers.

Two cells see each other when they share a row, a column, or a 3×3 block. On the cube, that holds on every face the cells belong to.

Each diagram shows a complete puzzle. The pencil notes always match the digits already placed on the board.

  • Grey digits are already placed in the puzzle. They show where the notes come from.
  • Orange: the row, column, or block you are examining. Digits inside it are dark.
  • Green: the digits or candidates that drive the deduction.
  • Red strikethrough: a candidate you can eliminate. A red × means that cell is ruled out.
  • Yellow: a cell whose digit is now forced.
  • A teal line along the border marks the shared edge between two faces.
  • Small digits are pencil notes. Just like in the app, each digit sits in a fixed slot: 1 at top-left through 9 at bottom-right.
  • When a step focuses on a single digit, the diagram shows only that digit’s notes everywhere it fits, just like digit highlighting in the app.
  • A frame marks the target cell being asked about.
  • Letters label cells referred to in the text. E is always a corner cell and K is always an edge cell.
  • A green circle around a digit highlights the digit that forces the deduction.
  • For corner techniques, the three faces are unfolded. A dashed line connects the edge that is split apart in the flat view.

All techniques at a glance

Example

Hidden Pair: a hidden pair in a block

In the center block, 2, 3, 5, 7, and 9 are still missing. Check each digit one by one: 3 appears only in Row 4, Column 4 and Row 6, Column 6, and 7 also appears only in Row 4, Column 4 and Row 6, Column 6. Both digits share those exact two cells.

No other digit can fit there. Eliminate 2 from Row 4, Column 4, and eliminate 5 and 9 from Row 6, Column 6. Both cells keep {3, 7}.

The center block is highlighted orange while all other cells are filled in grey. Green candidates 3 and 7 appear only in Row 4, Column 4 and Row 6, Column 6. In Row 4, Column 4, 2 is crossed out in red; in Row 6, Column 6, 5 and 9 are crossed out. The remaining three cells hold 2 and 5, 2 and 9, and 5 and 9.

Now glance at the other three cells of the block: together they hold only 2, 5, and 9 — a Naked Triple. Hidden and Naked Subsets are two sides of the same coin.

Hidden Triple: three digits, three cells

The same applies when three digits appear nowhere else in a group outside the same three cells. In Column 6, 2, 4, and 6 occur only in Row 2, Column 6, Row 4, Column 6, and Row 8, Column 6. Not every digit has to appear in all three cells, yet together those three digits can use only those three spots. Eliminate every other candidate there: 1 in Row 2, Column 6, 9 in Row 4, Column 6, and 7 in Row 8, Column 6.

Column 6 is highlighted orange while all other cells are filled in grey. Green candidates 2, 4, and 6 appear only in Row 2, Column 6, Row 4, Column 6, and Row 8, Column 6, where 1, 9, and 7 are crossed out in red. The other empty cells of the column hold 1 and 7, 7 and 9, and 1 and 9.

How to spot it

Exercise

In Row 7, two digits appear only in the same two cells. Which digits are they, and which candidates can you eliminate?

Row 7 is highlighted orange and contains placed digits 4, 9, 3, and 7; all other cells are filled in grey. Empty cells show candidates: Column 2 has 1, 2, 6, and 8; Column 4 has 1 and 2; Column 5 has 1 and 5; Column 7 has 2, 5, 6, and 8; Column 9 has 2 and 5.
Show solution

Both 6 and 8 appear only in Row 7, Column 2 and Row 7, Column 7, so those two cells belong to 6 and 8. Eliminate the other candidates there: 1 and 2 from Row 7, Column 2, and 2 and 5 from Row 7, Column 7. Both cells keep {6, 8}.

When a digit’s remaining spots in a block sit on one line, you get a Pointing Pair or Triple. When a digit’s spots in two rows line up in the same two columns, look for an X-Wing next.

All techniques